Compared by formula

Flour Tortillas

Compared by formula.

Lard or shortening, rested or not — the difference between a tortilla that rolls thin and one that fights back.

22recipes
18sites
1kcook ratings
113reviews read
15proven levers
Corn tortilla, medium flour tortilla, and large flour tortilla, stacked
Vigilantcosmicpenguin · CC BY 4.0

What kind do you like?

Pick one and the answer appears — everything else is optional

Start here

The one most cooks reach for

Nothing picked yet, so this is simply the most-rated version of the 22 we compared. Pick a style above and the answer changes.

Tonight:
Flour Tortillas
Vigilantcosmicpenguin · CC BY 4.0 · illustrates the dish, not this recipe
liquidfatsaltyeastflour proteinliquid · fat · salt · yeast · flour protein

Sourdough Flour Tortillas (made with discard or not)

from alexandracooks.com

★★★★★ 5 (219)
no mixerno chilling
hands-on30m
waitingnone
makes6
each$0.13
levelintermediate
Contains:dairygluten

Where your pick sits among all 22

Every dot is one published recipe, placed by its measured formula. The ring is your pick — click any other dot to see that version.

48% 95% 142% 4%16%27%39%51% lean → lard-rich stiffer → slacker dough your pick Sourdough Flour Tortillas (made with discard or not) — alexandracooks.com Homemade Flour Tortillas — isabeleats.com Homemade Flour Tortilla — natashaskitchen.com Flour Tortillas — gimmesomeoven.com Cassava Flour Tortillas (Gluten-Free Tortillas) — downshiftology.com Easy Homemade Flour Tortillas — alexandracooks.com Homemade Flour Tortillas — cookingclassy.com Homemade Flour Tortillas — favfamilyrecipes.com Flour Tortillas — tastesbetterfromscratch.com Flour Tortillas v.2.0 (low fat) — budgetbytes.com Cassava Flour Tortillas (Grain-Free) — minimalistbaker.com Flour Tortillas — jocooks.com Homemade flour tortillas — simply-delicious-food.com Flour Tortillas — budgetbytes.com Homemade Flour Tortillas — browneyedbaker.com Homemade Flour Tortilla — eatingonadime.com Flour Tortillas — kingarthurbaking.com Keto-Friendly Flour Tortillas — kingarthurbaking.com Homemade Flour Tortillas — momontimeout.com Homemade Flour Tortillas — twopeasandtheirpod.com Flour Tortilla — sugarspunrun.com Gluten-Free Flour Tortillas — kingarthurbaking.com

What cooks found out

Read from 113 reviews across all 22 recipes. The counts are how many cooks report it.

Dough that strays from the recipe's flour-to-water ratio in either direction - extra flour worked in to rescue a wet dough, extra water added to loosen a stiff one, or a flour-type swap like a gluten-free blend - reliably tanks workability (scores of 1-3), while dough kept close to spec stays workable across pizza, bagels, pretzels, and bread.

backed by 11 cooks

A cold ferment stretched to 18-48 hours in the fridge consistently deepens flavour and improves rise, and often eases shaping, across pizza dough, focaccia, and no-knead bread.

backed by 10 cooks

For bagels and pretzels, full submersion and adequate contact time in the baking-soda (or lye) bath - especially with molasses or brown sugar added - drives the browning (char depth) and crackly crust that a skipped or shortchanged bath fails to produce.

backed by 7 cooks

Uncontrolled top-heat exposure - matching top and bottom heat, baking uncovered too long, pooling egg wash, or burn-prone toppings - tips char depth into scorched territory; tenting with foil or avoiding those toppings keeps browning controlled.

backed by 5 cooks

All 22 flour tortillas recipes we measured

Each one has its own breakdown: formula, cost, time, and how it ranks.

Sourdough Flour Tortillas (made with discard or not) · 5★
Homemade Flour Tortillas · 4.78★
Homemade Flour Tortilla · 5★
Cassava Flour Tortillas (Gluten-Free Tortillas) · 4.72★
Flour Tortillas · 4.91★
Easy Homemade Flour Tortillas · 5★
Cassava Flour Tortillas (Grain-Free) · 4.12★
Homemade Flour Tortillas · 5★
Flour Tortillas v.2.0 (low fat) · 4.41★
Flour Tortillas · 4.65★
Homemade Flour Tortillas · 5★
Flour Tortillas · 4.8★
Homemade flour tortillas · 4.6★
Homemade Flour Tortillas · 4.88★
Flour Tortillas · 5★
Keto-Friendly Flour Tortillas · 4★
Homemade Flour Tortilla · 5★
Flour Tortillas · 5★
Flour Tortilla · 4.5★
Homemade Flour Tortillas · 5★
Homemade Flour Tortillas · 5★
Gluten-Free Flour Tortillas · 4★