The whole set

All 169 peanut butter cookies recipes

Grouped by the kind of cookie they actually make.

Every recipe we could resolve to grams, from 47 sites, sorted by how many cooks have rated it. The group is measured from the formula, not read off the title — which is why a few sit somewhere their own name would not suggest. Back to the recipe and the tweaks →

Chewy · 146

Dense, bending middle. Soft edge. Bends before it breaks.

Keto Peanut Butter Cookiesgluten-free3.6111112★ 18
Vegan Peanut Butter Cookiesegg-free4.87★ 15
Vegan Peanut Butter Cookiesegg-free4.85★ 13
Mug Cookie4.5★ 2

Crispy · 22

Thin, even snap all the way through. Spreads wide, bakes dry.

Cakey · 1 thin evidence

Tall and soft, closer to a muffin top. More lift, less spread.

Every recipe is its author's work and links to their page. Want the underlying table? Take the JSON.